A pilot across four Scottish health boards invited 2801 people aged 50-74 with a smoking history recorded in primary care to a lung health check. The response rate was 23.8%, lower in more deprived areas, and non-responders were more often current smokers. Of 436 high-risk participants scanned, lung cancer was diagnosed in 1.15% and coronary artery disease was identified in 56.4%.
Why it is interesting: Record-based recruitment reached a high-risk group, but response was modest and lower in more deprived areas.
Abstract — the authors' own words, CC BY
Objectives
To assess the feasibility and acceptability of delivering risk-stratified low-dose CT (LDCT) lung cancer screening across diverse geographical and socioeconomic settings in Scotland and to characterise uptake, participant profile and screening outcomes. Design
Prospective, multicentre pilot feasibility study with descriptive analysis. Setting
Primary and secondary care interface across four regional Health Boards in Scotland, encompassing urban, rural, remote and socioeconomically deprived populations. Participants
2801 individuals aged 50-74 years, identified from primary care electronic medical records (EMRs), with a history of smoking were invited (current or within 15 years where available); 668 (23.8%) responded. Of 608 assessed for eligibility (50.8% female; median age 63 years), 503 (82.7%) met at least one predefined high-risk criterion. Interventions
Invitation to a lung health check, followed by telephone-based risk assessment using US Preventative Services Task Force, Liverpool Lung Pathway version 2 and the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian Screening Trial criteria. High-risk participants were offered a one-off LDCT scan at local centres. Primary and secondary outcome measures
Primary: feasibility indicators including uptake, risk eligibility and scan completion. Secondary: prevalence of lung cancer, pulmonary nodules and incidental findings (eg, coronary artery disease, emphysema). Results
Response rate was 23.8% (668/2801), varying from 17.8% to 38.1% across practices and lower in more deprived areas. Of 503 eligible participants, 436 (86.7%) underwent LDCT. Abnormal findings were present in 83.3% of scans. Lung nodules were detected in 25.7% (112/436), with 11.8% requiring follow-up. Lung cancer was diagnosed in 1.15% (5/436; 95%), alongside five additional malignancies. Coronary artery disease was identified in 56.4% (246/436) and emphysema in 33% (144/436). Non-responders were more likely to be current smokers (69.3% vs 49.8%). Conclusions
Recruitment of people for lung cancer screening using the smoking history recorded in their primary care EMR is feasible. This approach identifies a high-risk population with a high burden of both malignant and non-malignant disease, and with substantial undiagnosed disease burden. However, uptake was modest and socially patterned, highlighting the need for equity-focused implementation strategies, including repeated invitations and targeted engagement. These findings are particularly relevant as Scotland considers implementation of a national lung cancer screening programme within a health system characterised by marked geographical and socioeconomic inequalities. Further research should evaluate long-term outcomes, cost-effectiveness and strategies to improve equitable participation.
Cite this item
BibTeX
Free sign-up. A digest of the new papers twice a week, grouped by domain.