COIOSDeep risk insights through multi-disciplinary research across the globe
white metal armchair lot
Item new Peer-reviewed Added

Dialysis facility mortality ratios without race adjustment favour high social-risk units

Dropping race and ethnicity from risk adjustment almost erased the mortality ratio gap between lowest and highest social-risk dialysis facilities.

The study examined how dropping race and ethnicity from CMS risk adjustment changes dialysis facility standardised mortality ratios (SMRs). It grouped 6,895 US facilities in 2017–2020 by shares of Black, Hispanic, deprived-area and uninsured or Medicaid-covered new patients. Mean SMR was 0.93 at lowest and 1.03 at highest social-risk facilities, a gap that vanished without race adjustment. Without race, 21.6% of highest-risk facilities moved up the SMR rankings, against 1.9% of lowest-risk facilities. Facilities with the most non-Hispanic Black patients gained most, with 26.6% improving against 4.7% of all others. The data cover 2017–2020, years before CMS removed the race fields in July 2025.

Why it is interesting: CMS removed race fields from the main source form for SMR risk adjustment in July 2025. The study shows which facilities' mortality ratios shift most when race is dropped.

Source
JAMA Internal Medicine, 16 November 2026
Paper
Removing Race From Standardized Mortality Ratio Risk Adjustment in Dialysis Care Quality Measurement
Authors
Koukounas KG, Boyang L, Schmid CH, Patzer RE, Wilk AS, Drewry KM et al.
DOI
10.1001/jamainternmed.2026.5632
Type
Peer-reviewed article
Design
Cross-sectional analysis of 6895 US dialysis facilities, USRDS/REMIS data 2017-2020, comparing race-inclusive and race-excluded SMR risk adjustment
Verdict
New finding
Driver
Health systems and access
Driver
Revisions and new sources

Other drivers in Data, models and systems