COIOSDeep risk insights through multi-disciplinary research across the globe
Coastal city with houses overlooking the ocean and distant hills
Item refines Peer-reviewed Added

Temperature-attributable mortality in Japan depends on the geographic level of analysis

Prefecture-level analysis gave 39.2% more heat-attributable deaths than municipality-level analysis in Japan, but only 1.4% more cold-attributable deaths.

It compared temperature-attributable mortality at municipality and prefecture level, using daily data from 1,845 Japanese municipalities, 2010-2019. Municipality analyses used 1-km gridded temperature and case-time-series; prefecture analyses used station temperature and time-series regression. The prefecture analysis gave 39.2% more heat-attributable deaths and 1.4% more cold-attributable deaths. Population-weighted rather than unweighted municipality temperature raised the municipality heat estimate by 16.0%. With the same gridded temperature and time-series model at both levels, the prefecture heat estimate stayed 17.6% higher. Cold gaps were smaller than heat gaps, but their size varied with model specification.

Why it is interesting: At prefecture level, heat estimates changed by under 1.5% whether station, gridded or population-weighted temperature was used. Keeping local correspondence between temperature and deaths appeared to matter more for heat burden than finer temperature data.

Source
Environmental Research, 9 November 2026
Paper
Spatial resolution and temperature-attributable mortality estimates: A nationwide study in Japan
Authors
He J, Honda Y, Madaniyazi L, Chua PLC, Tobias A, Hashizume M et al.
DOI
10.1016/j.envres.2026.126146
Type
Peer-reviewed article
Design
Nationwide methodological comparison of temperature-attributable mortality estimates, 1,845 Japanese municipalities, daily mortality and 1-km gridded temperature, 2010-2019; case-time-series vs conventional time-series regression
Verdict
Refines prior evidence
Driver
A changing climate
Abstract — the authors' own words, CC BY

Temperature-attributable mortality estimates are widely used to assess climate-related health risks, yet their comparability across spatial and analytical settings remains uncertain. We compared municipality- and prefecture-level estimates across Japan using daily mortality and temperature data from 1845 municipalities during 2010-2019. Municipality-level analyses used approximately 1-km gridded temperature and a case-time-series framework, whereas prefecture-level analyses used representative weather-station temperature and conventional time-series regression. Additional implementations examined differences associated with temperature representation, population weighting, analytical framework, and the geographic level at which temperature and mortality were linked. The prefecture-level analysis estimated 1.4% more cold-attributable deaths but 39.2% more heat-attributable deaths than the municipality-level analysis. Cold-related differences were generally smaller than heat-related differences across alternative implementations and sensitivity analyses, although their magnitudes varied with model specification. At the prefecture level, heat-attributable mortality varied by less than 1.5% across representative weather-station, prefecture-mean gridded, and population-weighted gridded temperatures. In contrast, replacing unweighted with population-weighted municipality temperature increased the municipality-level heat estimate by 16.0%. When both spatial levels used the same gridded temperature dataset and conventional time-series framework, the prefecture-level heat estimate remained 17.6% higher. These findings suggest that finer-resolution temperature data alone may have limited influence when summarized and linked to mortality at a broader geographic level. Retaining the local correspondence between temperature and mortality may be particularly important for heat-related burden estimation.

Other drivers in Tomorrow's world