COIOSDeep risk insights through multi-disciplinary research across the globe
aerial view of city buildings under cloudy sky during daytime
Item refines Preprint · not peer-reviewed Added

Smallpox vaccine effectiveness against death in Copenhagen epidemics of 1824 to 1835

Smallpox case fatality in Copenhagen, 1824 to 1834, was about 1% in vaccinated and 25% in unvaccinated patients.

Mandatory single-dose vaccination halted smallpox in Copenhagen by 1810, but it re-emerged in 1824 as an apparently milder adult disease. The study used physician reports on 3,795 quarantined patients from 1824 to 1835 to estimate case fatality and vaccine effectiveness. From 1824 to 1834, case fatality was about 1% vaccinated versus 25% unvaccinated, an effectiveness of about 95%. In the 1835 outbreak, case fatality among the vaccinated rose with age, read as waning protection. Almost no cases were over 40, suggesting lifelong immunity after infection. The abstract does not state the study's main limitation.

Why it is interesting: Smallpox returned in 1824 seemingly milder and affecting adults, but unvaccinated case fatality matched pre-vaccine levels. The authors attribute the shift to high vaccine coverage and protection waning in adulthood, not a weaker virus.

Source
medRxiv, 18 November 2026
Paper
The effect of smallpox vaccination: unique insights gained from Danish post-honeymoon epidemics 200 years ago
Authors
Eilersen A, Poder S, Goedknegt MJF, Pedersen AG, Ploug JB, Davenport RJ et al.
DOI
10.64898/2026.11.16.26368180
Type
Preprint
Design
Historical cohort analysis of 3,795 quarantined smallpox patients in Copenhagen, 1824-1835, with age, vaccination status and outcome; age-specific CFR and VE against mortality
Verdict
Refines prior evidence
Driver
Infection and pandemics
Abstract — the authors' own words, CC BY

Background:

Historically, the Variola virus caused deadly smallpox epidemics in children. In Copenhagen, transmission was halted by 1810 when ~90% of children were vaccinated following the introduction of a mandatory single-dose vaccine program. A 14-year honeymoon period followed, but in 1824 smallpox re-emerged as a milder disease of adults. We set out to study smallpox epidemics between 1824 and 1835 when all smallpox patients in Copenhagen were quarantined. Methods. We analyze data from 3795 smallpox patients reported by the treating physicians between 1824 and 1835. The data include age, vaccination status, and outcome. We estimate age-specific case fatality ratios (CFR) and vaccine effectiveness (VE) against mortality. Findings. For the four outbreaks while quarantine was mandatory (1824-1834), the CFR was ~1% among the vaccinated and ~25% among the unvaccinated, corresponding to a VE of ~95%. For the fifth outbreak in 1835, we found that CFR was low among the vaccinated but increased with age, which is evidence of waning vaccine protection. Almost no cases were over 40 years of age, suggesting lifelong immunity from smallpox infection. Interpretation. As the unvaccinated CFR was high and comparable to the pre-vaccine era, the milder post-honeymoon smallpox disease cannot be explained by genetic changes in the virus. Rather, high coverage with an effective vaccine combined with waning vaccine protection in adulthood explains the changing face of smallpox. We demonstrates how high vaccine coverage can disguise an outbreak of highly pathogenic smallpox as the milder Variola minor. Funding This study was funded by the Danish National Research Foundation (grant no. DNRF170).

Other drivers in Behavioural science